Hic Sunt Dracones

[email protected]

Trap Streets: Why Maps Contain Fake Streets and Towns

An aerial view of a road intersection in the middle of a desert Photo by Peter Orsel on Unsplash

Mapmakers sometimes lie on purpose. They slip small fake details into their maps, and they do it for a surprisingly good reason.

Professional mapmakers, or cartographers, have been doing this for about a hundred years. They add made-up streets and towns, called trap streets and paper towns, to catch rivals who copy instead of surveying the land themselves. This article explains how that trick works, how one fake town even became real for a while, and how researchers have now turned the same trick on AI.

What Is a Trap Street?

A trap street, also called a phantom street, is a fake street that a mapmaker plants on a map. Sometimes it’s a real street that’s been drawn wrong on purpose. Either way, its job is to catch anyone who copies the map without permission.

The street doesn’t exist, so no one doing an honest survey will ever find it. If it shows up on a rival’s map, you’ve almost certainly caught a copycat.

When mapmakers use a whole fake town this way, it’s called a paper town or a phantom settlement. Trap streets and paper towns are the mapmaking branch of a bigger family of copyright traps. That family also includes fake dictionary words and made-up encyclopedia entries.

Why Do Mapmakers Put Fake Streets on Maps?

Surveying means sending people out to measure the land, and it costs a lot. Copying someone else’s map is much cheaper. The hard part for an honest mapmaker is proving that someone copied, because accurate maps of the same place will naturally look very similar.

The fix was to add something that isn’t real. Fake entries in reference books go back even further than trap streets. One early example is “zzxjoanw,” the very last entry in a 1903 music dictionary by Rupert Hughes. The book claimed it was a Māori word meaning drum. No such word exists, and Māori doesn’t even use the letters Z, X, or J. Even so, it survived until 1976, and it’s still unclear whether Hughes meant it as a trap or a joke.

In 1975, the New Columbia Encyclopedia included Lillian Virginia Mountweazel, a fountain designer and photographer who never existed. Her entry says she died in an explosion while on assignment for Combustibles magazine. Fake entries like hers are now called Mountweazels, a term New Yorker writer Henry Alford coined in 2005.

Cartographers used the same trick on their maps. They’d add a fake alley, a made-up curve in a road, or an invented village at a quiet crossroads.

Did a Fake Town Really Become Real?

Yes, for a while. About a century ago, Otto G. Lindberg of the General Drafting Company and his assistant, Ernest Alpers, were making a road map of New York State. At a dirt-road junction in the Catskills, they added a tiny village that didn’t exist. They named it Agloe, an anagram of their initials (O.G.L. and E.A.).

Fictional copyright trap Agloe, New York, shown on a real 1998 Exxon (American map) state map of New York, United States.

Years later, Agloe turned up on a Rand McNally map, and Lindberg accused the rival publisher of copying. Rand McNally said Agloe was real, claiming county records showed a business by that name at the spot. People saw the name on gas-station maps and started using it. First as a fishing lodge, then as the Agloe General Store at the same spot. Agloe stayed on paper maps into the 1990s and even showed up on Google Maps until 2014. It’s also the destination in John Green’s 2008 novel Paper Towns. Fans of the book have made pilgrimages there, only to find a field and a barn.

Have Trap Streets Ever Caught a Copycat?

Sometimes, but one of the most famous map-copying cases didn’t need a fake street at all. In 1996, Ordnance Survey, Britain’s national mapping agency, sued the Automobile Association (AA). It said the AA had copied Ordnance Survey maps into its atlases, town plans and fold-out maps.

The AA denied it, but in 2001 it agreed to pay £20 million, settling on the courtroom steps. Ordnance Survey has said it doesn’t misname streets on purpose. Instead, its experts pointed to copied drawing-style details, such as road widths. Those quirks worked like fingerprints.

Outside mapmaking, the catches have been clearer. In 2001, the New Oxford American Dictionary added a fake word to protect its copyright. “Esquivalience” supposedly meant the willful avoidance of your official duties. It later turned up on Dictionary.com, credited to a different dictionary, and the site has since removed it.

About ten years later, Google suspected Bing of copying its search results. So it made up about 100 nonsense search terms, like “hiybbprqag,” and had each one bring up an unrelated page. Within weeks, some of those pages started showing up on Bing too. Google went public in 2011, and Microsoft denied copying.

Are Trap Streets Still Used Today?

Yes, though fake streets are harder to hide on digital maps. Satellite photos and GPS data show what’s really on the ground, and anyone who spots a street that isn’t there can report it.

Digital map data can carry a subtler mark instead. With digital watermarking, a publisher shifts coordinates in a tiny, systematic pattern that can later help prove copying in court.

Some fakes have made it onto digital maps anyway. Moat Lane in Finchley, North London, showed up on Google Maps and was still there in 2012. In satellite view, you could see it run straight over trees, gardens and a house. It came from Tele Atlas, a Dutch company that supplied map data to Google, and it’s widely seen as a copyright trap.

Not every phantom is a trap, though. In 2008, Google Maps showed a village called Argleton in West Lancashire, England, complete with job listings, homes and even dating profiles. The listings really belonged to other places in the same postcode, and Argleton itself was an empty field. Tele Atlas couldn’t explain how Argleton got into its data, and it was gone from Google Maps by 2010.

OpenStreetMap, a free map built by volunteers, rules out deliberate errors. It argues that its data already carries a fingerprint: what its volunteers chose to map, and the honest mistakes they made.

Many of the best-known examples come from printed street atlases. In 2005, a spokesperson for the Geographers’ A-Z Map Company told the BBC series Map Man that the London A-Z contained about 100 trap streets. Few have ever been confirmed, so that the number may be more legend than fact.

The example that keeps coming up is Bartlett Place on the Isle of Dogs, a real walkway the A-Z named after an employee, Kieran Bartlett. Later editions switched it back to its real name, Broadway Walk.

London’s Haggerston Park has appeared in the A-Z with a ski slope it has never had. In 2010, the park’s users group spent a meeting trying to work out why, and its minutes suggested it might be an Ordnance Survey blip.

In Bristol, the A-Z has added a dead-end street called Lye Close to Canynge Square. It isn’t in the atlas’s index, and it isn’t in Bristol either. The name is a hint, since “Lye” sounds just like “lie.”

A driver’s atlas of Athens is more upfront. It prints a warning inside the front cover, telling anyone thinking of copying the map to watch out for trap streets.

Can a Trap Street Catch an AI?

In a way, yes. In 2024, researchers at Imperial College London suggested hiding unique, made-up sentences in articles or books. These sentences are meant to work as copyright traps for large language models, the AI systems behind chatbots. If you own the text, the traps let you check later whether someone trained an AI model on it.

Lead researcher Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye said the phantom towns of early twentieth-century mapmakers inspired the idea. About a century after Agloe, the trap street has become a sentence.

Maps and dictionaries carry signatures, some planted on purpose and some left by accident. Copy the data, and you copy the signature too. Cartographers have known that for about a hundred years.

FAQ

Is Agloe, New York a real place?

No. Two mapmakers invented Agloe as a copyright trap about a century ago. It “became real” for a while when a local business took the name. Today it’s an unmarked rural crossroads in the Catskills, though fans of the novel Paper Towns have made pilgrimages there.

What is the difference between a trap street and a paper street?

A trap street is a fake street planted on purpose to catch copying. A paper street was planned for real: planners or developers laid it out on official maps, but nobody ever built it. Both show up on maps without existing on the ground, but only the trap street is a trick.

Why are fake settlements called paper towns?

They’re called paper towns because they exist only on maps, not in real life. In nineteenth-century America, speculators laid out and named new towns that sometimes never got past the map. Those were called paper towns too. John Green’s 2008 novel Paper Towns later tied the term to Agloe and to copyright traps.

Does Google Maps have fake streets?

Not on purpose, as far as anyone knows. Phantoms like Argleton and Moat Lane came from data Google licensed from Tele Atlas. When Argleton surfaced, Google said most of its map information was correct, but it occasionally had errors.

Is the trap street in Doctor Who real?

No, but “trap street” is a real mapmaking term. The 2015 episode “Face the Raven” borrowed the idea for a hidden London street where alien refugees take shelter. China Miéville’s 2010 novel Kraken did something similar, imagining London’s A-Z trap streets as hideouts for the city’s magical underground. Real trap streets have far fewer residents.

✍️